Literaturnachweis - Detailanzeige
Autor/in | Targovnik, Nina R. |
---|---|
Titel | An Invitation Extended To Critically Examine Whole Language: The Silent Student Speaks. |
Quelle | (1993), (16 Seiten)
PDF als Volltext |
Sprache | englisch |
Dokumenttyp | gedruckt; online; Monographie |
Schlagwörter | Stellungnahme; Elementary Education; Higher Education; Student Characteristics; Teacher Attitudes; Teacher Role; Whole Language Approach |
Abstract | Reacting to whole language zealots who are not willing to hear new viewpoints or engage in a dialogue with people who differ from their paradigm of education, a graduate student-teacher-researcher who is in general agreement with whole language principles responds to a series of conversations in which she was a listener but not a participant. The gist of each of the 12 conversations is given and discussed in turn. Her conclusions are that: (1) while her silence in these conversations was generally tolerated, those who advanced whole language felt there was no place for silence; (2) there is one basic philosophy of whole language that all must learn; (3) there is a "right" way for teachers to act in whole language classrooms; (4) whole language "zealots" have proclaimed that content areas are dead; (5) whole language advocates have proclaimed traditional tests as the work of the devil; (6) textbooks of all sorts are condemned; (7) whole language enthusiasts insist that aliterates are worse off than illiterates; (8) the idea that students need to manipulate texts and to become intimately involved in the writing process is a common "buzz phrase" of the whole language camp; (9) whole language advocates seem not to acknowledge that some students do not learn to read by merely reading; (10) whole language enthusiasts often ignore other voices or do not give others a chance to voice their opinions; (11) whole language advocates find that women have a unique way of thinking and feeling which is not valued by the schools, workplace, or society; and (12) whole language enthusiasts do not listen to people espousing non-politically correct views. (RS) |
Erfasst von | ERIC (Education Resources Information Center), Washington, DC |